What topic do I want to write about tonight?
Hurray! It’s another sketchy self-defense/homicide case that went international on the news! (sarcasm)
I read this on the New York Times. You can check it out at this article.
So what’s the story?
Diren Dede was a 17 year-old exchange student from Germany going to school in Montana.
He thought it’d be fun to go out and steal stuff from someone’s garage.
He found an open garage and went in to take some stuff.
The owners, Markus Kaarma and Janelle Pflager, were cautious because there had been other burglaries in the area.
They’d installed cameras and motion sensors in the garage.
They chose not to actually close the garage all the way because they like to duck under it to smoke outside.
Not closing the garage didn’t make sense to my Californian mind at first. Why not just open your door to go smoke?
The case is in cold Montana though. The couple probably smoke in their garage and just duck down to breathe the smoke outside.
Anyways, Markus Kaarma saw the motion detectors. He grabbed his shotgun and fired into the garage.
Janelle Pflager says she heard someone in the garage shouting, “Hey! Wait!”
Montana law gives someone the right to use a gun against a home invader only if the trespasser is violently threatening someone in the house.
That’s pretty clearly not the case.
To make it worse, Kaarma had spoken with his barber recently about wanting to “shoot some kid.”
And there’s a purse at the back of the garage that was placed there with marked items, so that if it was stolen they could track down the thief.
So… it’s almost a clear case of premeditation.
They didn’t burglar proof their house. They set up stuff to tell them if a thief was in the garage. And Markus talked about wanting to kill someone.
The facts as I see them make the case clearly second-degree murder, if not first.
People have the right to protect themselves and their property, but there is a limit to how far that protection goes.
Kaarma could use his gun for intimidation, but when he heard Dede telling him to wait, he should’ve realized that firing his gun was a bad choice.
All that aside, I’m also a little surprised he could afford bail for a murder case.
That’s all for tonight!
-Mister Ed
Leave a comment